The Club Med of Conferences   Leave a comment

The Club Med of Libertarian Conferences
Keir Martland
14th October 2015

Earlier this year, Hans-Hermann Hoppe invited me to his annual Property and Freedom Society (PFS) conference in Bodrum, Turkey. Having never been to Turkey before, I decided I would ask a good friend and colleague from the Libertarian Alliance, Sean Gabb, if I could travel with him. He responded, “If you think you can put up with me, let’s do it.”

At the airport, Sean and I had a chat over a coffee at the Jamie Oliver café about the ageing leftists and the young and vibrant right, evidenced by – apart from my good self at the Libertarian Alliance – the new generation of writers and activists for all manner of organisations, be it Breitbart, Young Independence, or indeed the Adam Smith Institute. I wasn’t convinced, but after a rare moment of optimism from Sean, we went to the duty free to get some whisky for Professor Hoppe.

Sean returned to his usual cheery self on the plane. “Because we’re in the middle of the plane, in the event of a crash, we are least likely to survive.” Then he fell asleep for the duration of the flight while I gawped out of the window.

We were picked up at the airport in Bodrum and taken to the Karia Princess Hotel where I was informed that I was in fact staying just across the road at the Hotel Diltua. I cannot fault either hotel. However, I did have a couple of traumas on the first day. First, my phone decided to stop working, meaning I would have to rely on my body clock to wake me up for the duration of the conference. Second, I found I couldn’t work the door to my hotel room. However, Jay Baykal (PFS’ Membership Secretary) did very kindly help me get to grips with ‘Turkish doors.’


Taken on the first day of the Property & Freedom Society conference 2015

After I had unpacked, I walked over to the Karia Princess to see who else had arrived, like me and Sean, a day early, on the 9th September. I had the good fortune of meeting Professor Richard Lynn and his wife. However controversial his area of study may be, he is a man of quality. Richard read History at Cambridge originally, but switched to Psychology in his second year.

When I told him it was my intention to read History, too, he asked, very subtly, “Have you no interest in the social sciences?”

“The social science faculties are mostly dominated by the left, Richard,” I replied

“Ah, but there is one area which the left have not taken over. Have you by any chance heard of-“

“Sociobiology, by any chance?” I interjected.

I then explained to him that I had not the head for numbers nor the stomach for opprobrium and ostracism that he obviously had. A nice man. I won’t have a word said against him in my company.

Dinner that evening was with Hans and Gulcin Hoppe and Sean. What to say about Professor Hoppe? He is without a doubt the most important libertarian economist and philosopher for at least a generation, and his more recent writings on history are of equal value. In person, he is a great raconteur and conversationalist. On the final night of PFS he slowly approached me and put his hand on my shoulder to say “Until now I had never ever heard the name ‘Keir.’ I was, however, aware of Keira Knightly.” I bet he was!

PFS 2015 (2)

Taken on the first day of the Property & Freedom Society conference 2015

There is also nothing wrong with Hoppe’s sense of humour. Aware of the potential comedic value of his German accent, he used it to great effect. In order to alert us that it was time to get ready for the next lecture, he would shout “Achtung, achtung!” He also had us in fits of laughter when he told us of how Murray Rothbard kept rabbits in his apartment, which he would sometimes take for walks down the streets of Brooklyn.

I did meet a few Americans at PFS, but I didn’t let it ruin the conference for me. I particularly enjoyed the company of Stephan Kinsella from the ‘Center for the Study of Innovative Freedom’ (C4SIF) and his quizzing me on the Glorious Revolution. A number of other interesting foreigners are worth mentioning: Christian Robitaille from Mises Canada; Juan Carpio from Universidad San Francisco; Joakim Fagerström from Mises Sweden; and many more. Sean and I weren’t the only Englishmen at PFS, however. Also present were Peter Brimelow of VDare, Andy Duncan of ‘Sound Money’ at Casey Research, and Andy Curzon of the Intellectual Minds conferences.

PFS 2015 (1)

Keir with Christian Robitaille and Barkha Herman at the 2015 meeting of the Property and Freedom Society

On the 14th September, there was the boat trip. We all walked down to the marina, sailed out into the Aegean, and had some lunch. Apart from the lengthy discussions of common law, limited liability, entrepreneurship, and the practicalities of getting the state out of the economy, what I most remember is the moment that we were all swarmed by wasps. Sean leant over to tell me, “Of course, a real man isn’t afraid of wasps.” Then, when a huge oriental hornet landed on the table, he changed his tune, “Oh, that’s alarming. I think I will go in the sea after all.”

Perhaps the most surreal moment of PFS 2015 was when, for some reason or other, a succession of gay anthems started booming out of the sound system. Suddenly, a lot of confused people found themselves having to talk over the sound of the Village People’s YMCA.

Another memorable moment was the firework display after a short speech from Dr Gulcin Hoppe, accompanied by Orf’s ‘O Fortuna.’ The effect was very dramatic indeed.

How to sum up PFS? Andy Duncan has said it is like being outside of the asylum for a week. Stephan Kinsella describes it as ‘the land of perpetual hangovers.’ I think the best description yet, though, was from Gulcin Hoppe’s speech on day one: it is the ‘club med’ of conferences!


Posted October 14, 2015 by keirmartland in Culture, Libertarianism, Reviews

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: